‘Paying someone $1 million a year for not working is the highest I’ve ever seen,’ says the director of a public pay database in California

By Jason Henry | jhenry@scng.com | Pasadena Star News
Published: July 2, 2021 at 7:00 a.m. | Updated: July 2, 2021 at 3:52 p.m.

A nearly $1 million payment to former Fontana City Manager Ken Hunt made him the highest paid city manager in California in 2020, though he didn’t actually work a single day that year.

The California State Controller’s Office cast a spotlight on Fontana this week after updating its public pay database with figures for 2020. In the state ranking, Hunt surpassed the next closest city manager’s wages by roughly $350,000.

The high pay and the lack of explanation for it from Fontana has raised eyebrows among taxpayer advocates. While golden handshakes for public employees aren’t unusual, most are in the $500,000 to $600,000 range, experts said.

Robert Fellner, executive director of Transparent California, has spent years collecting, compiling and publicizing public employees’ salaries. He’s seen his fair share of generous severance packages, he said. But when presented with the $932,623 paid to Hunt in 2020, his first instinct was that the number had to be an error.
The Latest: Russia faces surge of virus cases in last month

“Paying someone $1 million a year for not working is the highest I’ve ever seen,” he said.

‘Resigned to retire’

Officially, Hunt announced his retirement in July 2019, when he was roughly halfway through a five-year contract. City officials in news reports at the time painted it as a mutual decision. It wasn’t until months later that it was revealed that the well-liked city manager and the city had signed a settlement agreement outlining the terms of his resignation.

At the time, Mayor Acquanetta Warren stated Hunt “resigned to retire” and declined to discuss the reason why. Hunt’s contract and the settlement agreement suggest Hunt either received a sweetheart deal or had claims that could have cost the city much more.

If Hunt had resigned willingly, Fontana wouldn’t have owed him any severance, according to his most recent contract. Instead, the City Council went above and beyond even the 12 months of severance required if it had fired him without cause. Though he stopped working immediately in July 2019, the city agreed to pay him not only for the rest of 2019, but all of 2020 as well.
Allowed to reach 30 years of employment

The extra months, which were counted as paid leave, allowed Hunt to reach 30 years of employment and begin collecting a $16,707 monthly pension in February 2020, according to a settlement agreement released by the city and pension data collected by Transparent California.

Fontana ultimately paid Hunt $1,127,378 in wages and benefits from July 6, 2019, to January 31, 2020, according to calculations provided by the city. That’s roughly the equivalent of three years of Hunt’s 2019 wages.

The bulk of the payout — the $932,623 reported to the state controller — was spread across three paychecks in January 2020. It included $312,865 in “settlement pay,” $476,772 in leave payoff (equaling roughly a year-and-a-half of accrued leave), and an extra $64,137 for “longevity.”

In addition, Fontana paid a combined total of $386,582 to the two men who led the city in Hunt’s stead: interim City Manager Michael Milhiser, who managed the city from July 2019 until April 2020, and current City Manager Mark Denny, who was hired that April.

A spokesperson for the city provided a copy of the settlement agreement and the list of payments to Hunt. She referred back to the settlement agreement when asked why the city paid more than required by Hunt’s contract.

To read expanded article, click here.