August 4, 2016
A federal appeals court Thursday upheld the convictions of seven former Los Angeles County sheriff’s deputies on charges they tried to thwart an FBI investigation into county jails.
The unanimous decision by the three-judge panel from the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals clears the way for the former deputies, among them rank-and-file officers and mid-level commanders, to be sent to prison on lengthy sentences.
The ruling also deals a significant blow to Paul Tanaka, who ran much of the agency’s day-to-day operations as undersheriff and was convicted this year on the same set of charges. Tanaka, who was sentenced to five years in prison, vowed to appeal the jury’s decision on grounds similar to those raised by the deputies.
In reaching the decision, the appeals panel rejected an array of objections that attorneys for the group had made about the instructions U.S. District Court Judge Percy Anderson gave to jurors in two 2014 trials. Six of the deputies were tried together in one trial. The seventh was tried alone.
“There is little dispute about what Appellants did, but a good deal of conflict about why they did it — their intent, their motives, their purposes,” Judge Ferdinand F. Fernandez wrote in panel’s opinion. “They say that all was done for benign purposes but the Government says that what they did was for criminal purposes. Ultimately, a properly instructed jury had to decide whose narrative it believed.…These juries were properly instructed, and accepted the Government’s position.”
The cases stemmed from a 2011 fiasco that erupted when sheriff’s officials discovered the FBI was investigating allegations of widespread inmate abuse by deputies working in county jails. In an attempt to derail the probe, the deputies and Tanaka carried out a scheme to keep an inmate informant away from FBI agents, while also trying to intimidate an FBI agent and other deputies, jurors found.
To read expanded article, click here.