question-mark

Sunday, November 16, 2014 – 03:30 p.m.

Two criminal cases with a genesis from use-of-force shootings in the city of Upland have raised a serious ethical question.

Are meritless criminal charges filed in order to help an agency defend against a civil damage claim?

The first case in question is The People v. Jacob Kispi Katoa, San Bernardino County Superior Court Case No. FWV1202541.

The case filed on October 10, 2012, alleged that Katoa produced a firearm while being pursued by officers from the Upland Police Department. During his apprehension, Katoa was shot multiple times in the back, and side of his torso. He was subsequently charged with two counts of Assault with a Firearm on a Peace Officer [PC 245(D)(1)] and two counts of Assualt with a Semi-Automatic Rifle on a Peace Officer [PC 245(D)(2)].

How this charging scheme was rationalized is anyones guess.

Following a preliminary hearing Katoa was held to answer on the later two counts of PC 245(D)(2).

The case went to jury trial in August 2014. Katoa was acquitted on all counts after spending 22 months incustody.

The second case is The People v Christian Erwin Rodriguez, San Bernardino County Superior Court case No. FWV1300995.

This case, filed February 2013, also involves the aforementioned Upland Police Department. No we’re not picking on Upland. It just happens the instant examples occurred in that jurisdiction.

In this matter Rodriguez was accused of two counts of Assault on a Peace Officer Likely to Cause Great Bodily Injury [PC 245(C)], one count of Exhibiting a Firearm in the Presence of a Peace Officer [PC417(C)] and three counts of Obstructing/Resisting an Executive Officer [PC 69].

On September 9, 2014, after a change of legal counsel for Rodriguez, a preliminary hearing was held. During the hearing Defense Counsel Carl Douglas obtained admissions from the involved officers that the defendant had no firearm in his possession, and that no firearm was ever recovered. Officers also reluctantly admitted that Rodriguez was also shot several times in the back while face down on the ground. The firearm purported to be in Rodriguez’s waist turned out to be a folder containing homework from school.

Nevertheless charges were filed.

Superior Court Judge Jon Ferguson made no findings related to the two charges of PC245(C)(1) and two of the three counts of PC 69, meaning those charges were essentially dismissed. Ferguson’s ruling on charges of this magnitude is a rarity to say the least.

In the amended information filing, the District Attorney added two counts of misdemeanor Obstructing/Resisting a Peace Officer {PC 148(A)(1)]. A move presumably for plea bargain purposes.

Sources tell InlandPolitics.com that one misdemeanor plea offer has already been rejected.

The case is currently awaiting additional defense motions to dismiss.

Why would anyone ever bring charges in cases with the fact patterns such as we have here?

Here is the Jury Trial Docket on the Kotoa matter, and the complete Docket on the Rodriguez matter:

Case FWV1202541 Defendant 3918537 KATOA , JACOB KISPI – Defendants

Seq Defendant Next Court Date Status Agency /
DR Number
Arrest Date Count 1 Charge Violation Date
KATOA, JACOB KISPI      SH
601200271 
N/A  PC 245(D)(2)  10/05/2012 

Case FWV1202541 Defendant 3918537 KATOA , JACOB KISPI – Charges

Filed Charges
CountChargeSeverityDescriptionViolation DatePleaStatus
PC 245(D)(1) ASSAULT WITH FIREARM ON PEACE OFFICER/FIREFIGHTER 10/05/2012 NOT GUILTY HTA 
PC 245(D)(1) ASSAULT WITH FIREARM ON PEACE OFFICER/FIREFIGHTER 10/05/2012 NOT GUILTY HTA 
PC 245(D)(2) ASSAULT W/SEMIAUTOMATIC RIFLE ON PEACE OFFICER/FIREFIGHTER 10/05/2012  HTA 
PC 245(D)(2) ASSAULT W/SEMIAUTOMATIC RIFLE ON PEACE OFFICER/FIREFIGHTER 10/05/2012  HTA 
Infor Charges
CountChargeSeverityDescriptionViolation DatePleaStatus
PC 245(D)(2) ASSAULT W/SEMIAUTOMATIC RIFLE ON PEACE OFFICER/FIREFIGHTER 10/05/2012 NOT GUILTY ACQUITTED 
PC 245(D)(2) ASSAULT W/SEMIAUTOMATIC RIFLE ON PEACE OFFICER/FIREFIGHTER 10/05/2012 NOT GUILTY ACQUITTED 

Case FWV1202541 Defendant 3918537 KATOA , JACOB KISPI – Probation

Probation Has Not Been Granted On This Case For This Defendant.

Case FWV1202541 Defendant 3918537 KATOA , JACOB KISPI – Actions/Minutes

Action DateAction TextDispositionHearing Type
10/08/2014EXHIBIT(S) & EXHIBIT LIST RECEIVED FROM COURTROOM; CLERK’S COPY RETURNED TO COURTROOM.   
10/08/2014EXHIBITS LIST FILED.   
09/02/2014 9:30 AM DEPT. R14JURY TRIAL (DELIBERATIONS) DISPOSED  
Minutes
SHAHLA S SABET, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D4165-TERA SORENSEN
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: CB1-CHRISTINA BUSTAMANTE CSR# CB1-5529
BAILIFF E. BROCK
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JACK LIU PRESENT.
ATTORNEY RAJAN MALINE PRESENT.
DEFENDANT IN CUSTODY NOT PRESENT IN COURT.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR JURY TRIAL-IN PROGRESS
13TH DAY OF TRIAL.
AT 9:37 JURY REASSEMBLES AND DELIBERATIONS RESUME
REPORTER JM1-JULIA MEDINA BEGINS READBACK AT 9:40.
10:46
COURT REPORTER TAKES A BREAK FROM CONDUCTING READ
BACK.
10:57
COURT REPORTER RESUMES CONDUCTING READ BACK.
11:24
REPORTER JM1-JULIA MEDINA FINISHES READBACK AT 11:24.
11:57
JURY QUESTION(S) #4 IS RECEIVED .
JURY BREAKS FOR LUNCH.
PARTIES NOTIFIED BY JUDICIAL ASSISTANT.
AT 1:34 JURY REASSEMBLES AND DELIBERATIONS RESUME
1:42
COURT CONVENES AND ATTORNEYS ONLY ARE PRESENT.
DEFENSE COUNSEL WAIVES PRESENCE OF DEFENDANT.
JURY QUESTIONS 1 THROUGH 3 ARE RECITED INTO THE
RECORD.
DISCUSSIONS HELD ON THE RECORD RE: JURY QUESTION
#4.
1:58
JURY RETURNS TO THE JURY DELIBERATION ROOM TO
CONTINUE DELIBERATING.
RECESS DECLARED AT THIS TIME.
2:23
JURY ADVISES COURT THAT THEY: HAVE REACHED A VERDICT.
PARTIES ADVISED BY JUDICIAL ASSISTANT.
2:46
DEFENDANT IS NOW PRESENT.
COURT RECONVENES AND ALL PARTIES ARE PRESENT.
VERDICT
WE THE JURY IN THE ABOVE-ENTITLED ACTION, FIND THE DEFENDANT, JACOB KISPI KATOA, NOT GUILTY, IN COUNT 1, A VIOLATION OF SECTION 245(D)(2) PC.
WE THE JURY IN THE ABOVE-ENTITLED ACTION, FIND THE DEFENDANT, JACOB KISPI KATOA, NOT GUILTY, IN COUNT 2, A VIOLATION OF SECTION 245(D)(2) PC.
JURORS POLLED ON VERDICT(S).
RE-READING OF VERDICT WAIVED.
COURT GIVES CONCLUDING JURY INSTRUCTIONS.
2:51
JURORS THANKED AND EXCUSED.
COURT IS ADJOURNED.
EXHIBIT(S) SENT TO EXHIBIT CLERK.
CUSTODY STATUS
DEFENDANT RELEASED.
RELEASE ISSUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
08/29/2014 9:30 AM DEPT. R14JURY TRIAL (DELIBERATIONS) DISPOSED  
Minutes
SHAHLA S SABET, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D4165-TERA SORENSEN
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: LLA-LAURA ARTHUR CSR# LLA-9692
BAILIFF E. BROCK
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JACK LIU PRESENT.
ATTORNEY RAJAN MALINE PRESENT.
DEFENDANT IN CUSTODY NOT PRESENT IN COURT.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR JURY TRIAL-IN PROGRESS
12TH DAY OF TRIAL.
AT 9:35 JURY REASSEMBLES AND DELIBERATIONS RESUME
10:47
JURY QUESTION(S) #1 IS RECEIVED .
10:56
JURY QUESTION(S) #2 IS RECEIVED .
JUDICIAL ASSISTANT NOTIFIED PARTIES.
PARTIES STIPULATE TO WAIVE THEIR PRESENCE AS WELL
AS DEFENDANTS FOR COURT TO ADDRESS JURY RE:
JURY QUESTION #1.
PARTIES STIPULATE FOR COURT REPORTER TO CONDUCT
READ BACK AS REQUESTED IN JURY QUESTION #2.
11:25
COURT CONVENES AND JURY IS PRESENT.
PEOPLE DEFENSE AND DEFENDANTS PRESENCE WAIVED.
COURT ADDRESS JURORS RE: JURY QUESTION #1.
11:29
JURY RETURNS TO THE JURY DELIBERATION ROOM TO
RESUME DELIBERATING.
REPORTER JM1-JULIA MEDINA BEGINS READBACK AT 11:43.
12:00
JURY BREAKS FOR LUNCH.
AT 1:37 JURY REASSEMBLES AND DELIBERATIONS RESUME
REPORTER JM1-JULIA MEDINA BEGINS READBACK AT 1:37.
REPORTER JM1-JULIA MEDINA FINISHES READBACK AT 1:58.
3:06
JURY QUESTION(S) #3 IS RECEIVED .
JUDICIAL ASSISTANT NOTIFIED PARTIES.
3:28
JURY CONCLUDES DELIBERATIONS FOR THE DAY.
HEARINGS
JURY TRIAL (JURY DELIBERATION) CONTINUED TO 09/02/2014 AT 9:30 IN DEPARTMENT R14.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – IN CUSTODY
BAIL REMAINS AS SET.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
08/28/2014 10:30 AM DEPT. R14JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) DISPOSED  
Minutes
SHAHLA S SABET, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D4165-TERA SORENSEN
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: JM1-JULIA MEDINA CSR# JM1-10689
BAILIFF E. BROCK
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JACK LIU PRESENT.
ATTORNEY RAJAN MALINE PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR JURY TRIAL-IN PROGRESS
11TH DAY OF TRIAL.
10:42
COURT CONVENES OUTSIDE THE PRESENCE OF JURORS.
DISCUSSIONS HELD ON THE RECORD RE: EXHIBITS AND
CLOSING ARGUMENTS.
10:46
ALL JURORS AND ALTERNATE JUROR ARE NOW PRESENT
AND IN THEIR PROPER PLACES.
COURT GIVES JURY INSTRUCTIONS.
11:14
CLOSING ARGUMENTS PRESENTED BY THE PEOPLE.
11:44
RECESS DECLARED; JURORS ADMONISHED.
1:47
COURT RECONVENES AND JUROR #22 IN SEAT 4 IS NOT PRESENT.
1:51
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
BENCH CONFERENCE ENDS AT 1:53.
BAILIFF SPOKE WITH JUROR #22 IN SEAT 4 AND HE
INDICATED HE WOULD BE IN COURT WITHIN 5 MINUTES.
1:56
ALL JURORS AND ALTERNATE JUROR ARE NOW PRESENT
AND IN THEIR PROPER PLACES.
PEOPLE CONTINUE THEIR CLOSING ARGUMENTS.
2:56
RECESS DECLARED; JURORS ADMONISHED.
3:07
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL JURORS AND ALTERNATE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PLACES.
CLOSING ARGUMENTS PRESENTED BY DEFENSE.
3:49
FINAL CLOSING ARGUMENTS PRESENTED BY PEOPLE.
4:06
COURT GIVES JURY INSTRUCTIONS.
4:13
BAILIFF SWORN.
COURT ADDRESSES JURORS RE: SCHEDULE DURING
DELIBERATIONS.
4:15
JURY ADMONISHED AND COMMENCES DELIBERATIONS.
COURT GIVES JURY INSTRUCTIONS TO ALTERNATE JUROR.
4:18
ALTERNATE JUROR PLACED ON CALL WITH THE COURT;
IS ADMONISHED AND RELEASED UNTIL FURTHER NOTICE.
OUTSIDE THE PRESENCE OF JURORS:
DISCUSSIONS HELD ON THE RECORD RE: DELIBERATIONS.
COURT ALLOWS DEFENSE COUNSEL TO APPEAR
TELEPHONICALLY FOR ANY JURY QUESTIONS.
DEFENDANT WAIVES COUNSELS PERSONAL PRESENCE
FOR JURY QUESTIONS.
4:20
COURT IS ADJOURNED.
4:28
JURY CONCLUDES DELIBERATIONS FOR THE DAY.
HEARINGS
JURY TRIAL (JURY DELIBERATION) CONTINUED TO 08/29/2014 AT 9:30 IN DEPARTMENT R14.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – IN CUSTODY
BAIL REMAINS AS SET.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
08/27/2014 10:30 AM DEPT. R14JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) DISPOSED  
Minutes
SHAHLA S SABET, J-JUDGE
CLERK: VYG-VALERIE GUTIERREZ
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: JM1-JULIA MEDINA CSR# JM1-10689
BAILIFF E. BROCK
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JACK LIU PRESENT.
ATTORNEY RAJAN MALINE PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR JURY TRIAL-IN PROGRESS
10TH DAY OF TRIAL.
10:25
OUTSIDE THE PRESENCE OF THE JURORS ALL PARTIES
PRESENT.
COURT AND COUNSEL DISCUSS AN EXPERT WITNESS.
10:32
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL JURORS AND ALTERNATE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PLACES.
10:33
PEOPLE’S WITNESS ALFREDO PARRA JR. SWORN AND TESTIFIES.
10:41
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
10:42
PEOPLE’S WITNESS ALFREDO PARRA JR. RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH.
10:59
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
11:00
PEOPLE’S WITNESS ALFREDO PARRA JR. RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH.
RECESS DECLARED AT 11:58
COURT RECONVENES AT 1:31
1:35
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL JURORS AND ALTERNATE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PLACES.
1:36
PEOPLE’S WITNESS ALFREDO PARRA JR. RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH.
1:57
WITNESS ALFREDO PARRA JR EXCUSED.
PEOPLE REST.
1:58
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
DEFENSE WITNESS, RANDOLPH BEASLEY IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES.
2:09
WITNESS RANDOLPH BEASLEY EXCUSED.
DEFENSE REST.
JURORS ADMONISHED; COURT ADJOURNED AND JURORS ORDERED TO RETURN ON 08/27/14..
2:11
OUTSIDE THE PRESENCE OF THE JURY COURT AND COUNSEL
DISCUSS JURY INSTRUCTIONS.
RECESS DECLARED AT 2:46
HEARINGS
JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) CONTINUED TO 08/28/2014 AT 10:30 IN DEPARTMENT R14.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – IN CUSTODY
BAIL REMAINS AS SET.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
08/26/2014 10:30 AM DEPT. R14JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) DISPOSED  
Minutes
SHAHLA S SABET, J-JUDGE
CLERK: MV-MARY VIZCARRA
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: JM1-JULIA MEDINA CSR# JM1-10689
BAILIFF E. BROCK
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JACK LIU PRESENT.
ATTORNEY RAJAN MALINE PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR JURY TRIAL-IN PROGRESS
9TH DAY OF TRIAL.
10:40
COURT CONVENES OUTSIDE THE PRESENCE OF THE JURY.
COURT AND COUNSEL DISCUSS OFFER OF PROOF REGARDING
REBUTTAL WITNESS(ES) AND EXHIBITS.
DEFENDANT’S PRESENCE WAIVED.
10:49
DEFENDANT NOW PRESENT.
DISCUSSIONS CONTINUE.
10:52
JURY NOW PRESENT.
DEFENSE WITNESS RANDOLPH BEASLEY RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH.
COURT EXHIBIT(S) #227 ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
COURT EXHIBIT(S) #227 ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE.
COURT EXHIBIT(S) #228 AND #229 ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
COURT EXHIBIT(S) #227 AND #228 ENTERED INTO
EVIDENCE.
COURT EXHIBIT(S) #230 ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
COURT EXHIBIT(S) #230 ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE.
COURT EXHIBIT(S) #234 AND #235 ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
COURT EXHIBIT(S) #234 AND #235 ENTERED INTO
EVIDENCE.
11:52
JURORS ADMONISHED AND EXCUSED FOR NOON RECESS.
11:53
COURT IN RECESS.
13:30
CLERK: D3106-DAISY CENTENO
COURT RECONVENES AT 13:41 – ALL PARTIES PRESENT; JURY NOT PRESENT.
13:42
COURT REVIEWS POWERPOINT PRESENTATION WITH COUNSEL
ON THE RECORD.
13:47
DEFENSE WITNESS RANDOLPH BEASLEY RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH.
13:57
COURTS EXHIBIT(S) #231 AND #232 ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
COURT EXHIBIT(S) #231 AND #232 ENTERED INTO
EVIDENCE.
14:43
WITNESS RANDOLPH BEASLEY EXCUSED.
DEFENSE REST.
14:44
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
BENCH CONFERENCE ENDS AT 14:44.
14:45
RECESS DECLARED; JURORS ADMONISHED.
14:46
OUTSIDE THE PRESENCE OF THE JURY THE COURT
ADDRESSES WITNESSES TO BE CALLED AFTER RECESS
AND POSSIBILITY OF 402 EC MOTION TO BE HEARD
ON THE RECORD WITH COUNSEL.
RECESS DECLARED AT 14:50.
15:03
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL JURORS AND ALTERNATE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PLACES.
PEOPLE’S RE-REBUTTAL.
15:04
PEOPLE’S WITNESS CAROL FOSTORY SWORN AND TESTIFIES.
15:11
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
BENCH CONFERENCE ENDS AT 15:13.
15:53
WITNESS CAROL FOSTORY EXCUSED.
RECESS DECLARED; JURORS ADMONISHED.
15:54
OUTSIDE THE PRESENCE OF THE JURY THE COURT
REVIEWS POWERPOINT PRESENTATION WITH COUNSEL ON
THE RECORD.
COURT MAKES INQUIRES AS TO WITNESS DETECTIVE
PARRAS EXPERTISE.
JURY INSTRUCTIONS TO BE TURNED IN BY TOMORROW
AUGUST 28 2014 AT 8:30AM.
RECESS DECLARED AT 16:11.
HEARINGS
JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) CONTINUED TO 08/27/2014 AT 10:30 IN DEPARTMENT R14.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – IN CUSTODY
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
08/25/2014 8:30 AM DEPT. R14JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) DISPOSED  
Minutes
SHAHLA S SABET, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D4165-TERA SORENSEN
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: JM1-JULIA MEDINA CSR# JM1-10689
BAILIFF E. BROCK
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JACK LIU PRESENT.
ATTORNEY RAJAN MALINE PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR JURY TRIAL-IN PROGRESS
8TH DAY OF TRIAL.
9:30
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
BENCH CONFERENCE ENDS AT 9:34.
BAILIFF IS DIRECTED TO CONTACT THE JURY TO ADVISE
THEM TO BE PRESENT AT 1:30PM INSTEAD OF 11:00AM.
1:35
COURT CONVENES OUTSIDE THE PRESENCE OF JURORS.
DISCUSSIONS HELD ON THE RECORD RE: PROPOSED
POWERPOINT PRESENTATION FROM DEFENSES EXPERT.
SUBPOENAED RECORDS FROM ARROWHEAD REGIONAL MEDICAL
CENTER PREVIOUSLY RELEASED TO DDA JACK LIU ON
ON 08/06/2013 ARE RETURNED TO THE COURT PER COURT
ORDER.
COURT EXHIBIT(S) 226 ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
COURT EXHIBIT 226 ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE.
2:05
DEFENSE WITNESS, RANDOLPH BEASLEY IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES.
3:30
RECESS DECLARED; JURORS ADMONISHED.
3:49
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL PROSPECTIVE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PROPER PLACES
DEFENSE WITNESS RANDOLPH BEASLEY RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH.
4:26
JURORS ARE ADMONISHED; RELEASE AND ORDERED TO
RETURN ON 08/26/2014 AT 10:30AM.
OUTSIDE THE PRESENCE OF JURORS:
DISCUSSION HELD ON THE RECORD.
PARTIES STIPULATE TO THE FOLLOWING:
COURTS EXHIBIT WHICH WAS PREVIOUSLY ENTERED INTO
EVIDENCE AS EXHIBIT 219 IS NOW EXHIBIT 219A.
COURTS EXHIBIT(S) 219 220A 221A 222A 222AA 222B
222BA 222C 222CA 222D 222DA 222E 222EA 222F 222FA
222G AND 222GA ARE ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE.
WITNESS DETECTIVE AL PARRA ORDERED TO RETURN ON 08/26/2014 AT 10:30AM.
4:30
COURT IS ADJOURNED.
4:31
DEFENSE COUNSEL REQUESTS TO GO BACK ON THE RECORD.
DEFENDANT’S PRESENCE WAIVED.
DISCUSSIONS HELD ON THE RECORD RE: PEOPLES
REBUTTAL WITNESS.
4:32
COURT IS ADJOURNED.
HEARINGS
JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) CONTINUED TO 08/26/2014 AT 10:30 IN DEPARTMENT R14.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – IN CUSTODY
BAIL REMAINS AS SET.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
==MINUTE ORDER CHANGED OR CORRECTED BY TERA SORENSEN TO DISPO HEARING; CHANGES MADE ARE AS FOLLOWS: CHANGE VERBIAGE RE: SUBP RECORDS==
=======MINUTE ORDER CORRECTED ON 09/03/2014==========
08/21/2014 10:30 AM DEPT. R14JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) DISPOSED  
Minutes
SHAHLA S SABET, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D6022-AMBER ANDERSON
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: JM1-JULIA MEDINA CSR# JM1-10689
BAILIFF E. BROCK
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JACK LIU PRESENT.
ATTORNEY RAJAN MALINE PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR JURY TRIAL-IN PROGRESS
7TH DAY OF TRIAL.
10:30
HEARING HELD OUTSIDE PRESENCE OF THE JURY.
STIPULATION BY ATTORNEYS FOR EXHIBITS 4-199
BE ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE IF NOT ALREADY DONE SO.
COURTS EXHIBITS: 16 17 20 21 23 24 25 26 27 28 29
31 32 33 34 37 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53
54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 92 95 96 97 99 101 103
104 105 107 109 111 113 115 116 117 118 119
120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130
131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141
142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152
153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163
164 165 166 167 168 170 171 172 173 174 175
176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186
187 188 189 190 191 192 193 195 196 197 198 199
ARE ALL IDENTIFIED AND ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE
10:39
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL JURORS AND ALTERNATE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PLACES.
PEOPLE’S WITNESS STEVEN PENNINGTON RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH.
11:49
RECESS DECLARED UNTIL 1:30PM
13:35
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL JURORS AND ALTERNATE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PLACES.
PEOPLE’S WITNESS STEVEN PENNINGTON RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH.
COURTS EXHIBIT(S) 225 225A ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
EXHIBITS 225 225A ARE ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE
EXHIBIT 225 PLAYED IN OPEN COURT
14:11
WITNESS STEVEN PENNINGTON SUBJECT TO RECALL.
PEOPLE’S WITNESS CHRISTI BONAR SWORN AND TESTIFIES.
14:31
WITNESS CHRISTI BONAR EXCUSED.
PEOPLE’S WITNESS JASON MCCAULEY SWORN AND TESTIFIES.
14:37
WITNESS JASON MCCAULEY EXCUSED.
PEOPLE REST.
RECESS DECLARED UNTIL 3:00PM
15:00
HEARING HELD OUTSIDE PRESENCE OF THE JURY.
15:07
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL JURORS AND ALTERNATE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PLACES.
DEFENSE WITNESS, SHARON MOORE IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES.
15:29
WITNESS SHARON MOORE SUBJECT TO RECALL.
COURT IS ADJOURNED. JURORS ADMONISHED.
HEARING HELD OUTSIDE PRESENCE OF THE JURY.
HEARINGS
JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) CONTINUED TO 08/25/2014 AT 8:30 IN DEPARTMENT R14.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – IN CUSTODY
BAIL REMAINS AS SET.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
08/20/2014 10:30 AM DEPT. R14JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) DISPOSED  
Minutes
SHAHLA S SABET, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D6022-AMBER ANDERSON
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: JM1-JULIA MEDINA CSR# JM1-10689
BAILIFF E. BROCK
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JACK LIU PRESENT.
ATTORNEY RAJAN MALINE PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR JURY TRIAL-IN PROGRESS
6TH DAY OF TRIAL.
10:35
HEARING HELD OUTSIDE PRESENCE OF THE JURY.
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL JURORS AND ALTERNATE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PLACES.
PEOPLE’S WITNESS KEVIN CUSHMAN RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH.
COURTS EXHIBIT(S) 114 ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
EXHIBIT 114 IS ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE
11:01
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
BENCH CONFERENCE ENDS AT 1105.
COURTS EXHIBIT(S) 194 108 110 112 100 102 106 19 18 ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
COURTS EXHIBIT(S) 22 30 36 94 93 98 ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
EXHIBITS 194 108 110 112 100 102 106
19 18 22 30 36 94 93 98 ARE ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE
11:26
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
BENCH CONFERENCE ENDS AT 1127.
11:47
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
BENCH CONFERENCE ENDS AT 1148.
12:00
RECESS DECLARED UNTIL 1:30PM
13:35
HEARING HELD OUTSIDE PRESENCE OF THE JURY.
13:36
CONFERENCE WITH JUROR #5
13:39
HEARING HELD OUTSIDE PRESENCE OF THE JURY.
13:41
CONFERENCE WITH JUROR #5
13:43
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL JURORS AND ALTERNATE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PLACES.
PEOPLE’S WITNESS KEVIN CUSHMAN RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH.
14:04
WITNESS KEVIN CUSHMAN SUBJECT TO RECALL.
PEOPLE’S WITNESS DANIEL RODRIGUEZ SWORN AND TESTIFIES.
COURTS EXHIBIT(S) 210 211 212 210A 211A 212A ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
EXHIBITS 210 211 212 210A 211A 212A ARE ENTERED
INTO EVIDENCE
14:12
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
BENCH CONFERENCE ENDS AT 1413.
14:13
HEARING HELD OUTSIDE PRESENCE OF THE JURY.
14:30
RECESS DECLARED TILL 2:45PM
14:45
HEARING HELD OUTSIDE PRESENCE OF THE JURY.
14:57
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL JURORS AND ALTERNATE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PLACES.
PEOPLE’S WITNESS DANIEL RODRIGUEZ RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH.
EXHIBIT 210 PLAYED IN OPEN COURT
EXHIBIT 211 PLAYED IN OPEN COURT
EXHIBIT 212 PLAYED IN OPEN COURT
15:03
PEOPLE’S WITNESS DANIEL RODRIGUEZ RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH.
15:28
WITNESS DANIEL RODRIGUEZ EXCUSED.
PEOPLE’S WITNESS STEVEN PENNINGTON SWORN AND TESTIFIES.
15:41
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
BENCH CONFERENCE ENDS AT 1542.
COURTS EXHIBIT(S) 38 39 40 41 42 43 35 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
COURTS EXHIBIT(S) 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
EXHIBITS 38 39 40 41 42 43 35 74 75 76 77 78 79 80
81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 ARE ENTERED
INTO EVIDENCE
COURTS EXHIBIT(S) 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
EXHIBITS 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 ARE
ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE
16:09
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
BENCH CONFERENCE ENDS AT 1610.
16:10
COURT IS ADJOURNED. JURORS ADMONISHED.
HEARING HELD OUTSIDE PRESENCE OF THE JURY.
16:20
COURT IS ADJOURNED
HEARINGS
JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) CONTINUED TO 08/21/2014 AT 10:30 IN DEPARTMENT R14.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – IN CUSTODY
BAIL REMAINS AS SET.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
08/19/2014 10:30 AM DEPT. R14JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) DISPOSED  
Minutes
SHAHLA S SABET, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D6022-AMBER ANDERSON
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: JM1-JULIA MEDINA CSR# JM1-10689
BAILIFF E. BROCK
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JACK LIU PRESENT.
ATTORNEY RAJAN MALINE PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR JURY TRIAL-IN PROGRESS
5TH DAY OF TRIAL.
10:33
HEARING HELD OUTSIDE PRESENCE OF THE JURY.
10:35
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL JURORS AND ALTERNATE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PLACES.
PEOPLE’S WITNESS RUBEN CERVANTES SWORN AND TESTIFIES.
11:00
WITNESS RUBEN CERVANTES SUBJECT TO RECALL.
PEOPLE’S WITNESS ANDREW MCCULLOUGH SWORN AND TESTIFIES.
COURTS EXHIBIT(S) 9 218 10 11 13 3 3A ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
EXHIBITS 9 218 10 11 13 3 3A ARE ENTERED INTO
EVIDENCE
11:35
EXHIBIT #3 IS PLAYED IN OPEN COURT
11:45
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL CONFER IN CHAMBERS
11:50
COURTS EXHIBIT(S) 219 220 15 ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
EXHIBITS 219 220 15 ARE ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE
11:56
RECESS DECLARED UNTIL 1:30PM
13:32
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL JURORS AND ALTERNATE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PLACES.
PEOPLE’S WITNESS ANDREW MCCULLOUGH RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH.
COURTS EXHIBIT(S) 221 207 207A ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
EXHIBITS 221 207 207A ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE
COURTS EXHIBIT(S) 214 222 ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
EXHIBIT 207 PLAYED IN OPEN COURT
14:15
PEOPLE’S WITNESS ANDREW MCCULLOUGH RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH.
14:23
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
14:27
PEOPLE’S WITNESS ANDREW MCCULLOUGH RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH.
COURTS EXHIBIT(S) 223 ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
14:51
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
RECESS DECLARED FOR 15 MINUTES
HEARING HELD OUTSIDE PRESENCE OF THE JURY.
15:11
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL JURORS AND ALTERNATE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PLACES.
PEOPLE’S WITNESS ANDREW MCCULLOUGH RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH.
15:18
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
15:19
PEOPLE’S WITNESS ANDREW MCCULLOUGH RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH.
15:20
WITNESS ANDREW MCCULLOUGH SUBJECT TO RECALL.
PEOPLE’S WITNESS VICKY ORTIZ SWORN AND TESTIFIES.
COURTS EXHIBIT(S) 216 216A 217 217A ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
EXHIBITS 216 216A 217 217A ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE
15:25
EXHIBIT 216 PLAYED IN OPEN COURT
EXHIBIT 217 PLAYED IN OPEN COURT
15:30
WITNESS VICKY ORTIZ SUBJECT TO RECALL.
PEOPLE’S WITNESS KEVIN CUSHMAN SWORN AND TESTIFIES.
16:05
WITNESS KEVIN CUSHMAN SUBJECT TO RECALL.
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
COURT IS ADJOURNED. JURORS ADMONISHED.
HEARING HELD OUTSIDE PRESENCE OF THE JURY.
HEARINGS
JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) CONTINUED TO 08/20/2014 AT 10:30 IN DEPARTMENT R14.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – IN CUSTODY
BAIL REMAINS AS SET.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
08/18/2014 10:30 AM DEPT. R14JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) DISPOSED  
Minutes
SHAHLA S SABET, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D6022-AMBER ANDERSON
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: JM1-JULIA MEDINA CSR# JM1-10689
BAILIFF E. BROCK
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JACK LIU PRESENT.
ATTORNEY RAJAN MALINE PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR JURY TRIAL-IN PROGRESS
4TH DAY OF TRIAL.
10:30
HEARING HELD OUTSIDE PRESENCE OF THE JURY.
JUROR #22 HAS CALLED AND IS TOO SICK TO ATTEND
COURT TODAY.
10:47
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL JURORS AND ALTERNATE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PLACES.
EXCEPT FOR JUROR #22
10:52
HEARING HELD OUTSIDE PRESENCE OF THE JURY.
11:04
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL JURORS AND ALTERNATE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PLACES.
JURY IS EXCUSED FOR THE DAY
11:07
HEARING HELD OUTSIDE PRESENCE OF THE JURY.
11:27
COURT IS ADJOURNED. JURORS ADMONISHED.
HEARINGS
JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) CONTINUED TO 08/19/2014 AT 10:30 IN DEPARTMENT R14.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – IN CUSTODY
BAIL REMAINS AS SET.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
08/14/2014 1:30 PM DEPT. R14JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) DISPOSED  
Minutes
SHAHLA S SABET, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D6022-AMBER ANDERSON
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: LM1-LYNETTE MILAKOVICH CSR# LM1-5098
BAILIFF E. BROCK
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JACK LIU PRESENT.
ATTORNEY RAJAN MALINE PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR JURY TRIAL-IN PROGRESS
3RD DAY OF TRIAL.
13:33
HEARING HELD OUTSIDE PRESENCE OF THE JURY.
MOTION TO EXCLUDE WITNESSES, GRANTED. PEOPLE DESIGNATE DANIEL RODRIGUEZ AS INVESTIGATING OFFICER AND IS EXEMPT FROM THE EXCLUSION.
MOTION TO EXCLUDE WITNESS FOR DEFENSE PAUL ENGELS
IS GRANTED
13:41
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL JURORS AND ALTERNATE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PLACES.
OPENING STATEMENTS PRESENTED BY THE PEOPLE.
13:51
OPENING STATEMENTS PRESENTED BY THE DEFENSE.
14:05
COURTS EXHIBIT(S) 4 5 6 7 ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
EXHIBITS 4 5 6 7 ARE ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE
14:11
COURTS EXHIBIT(S) 1 1A ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
EXHIBITS 1 1A ARE ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE
EXHIBIT 1 IS PLAYED IN OPEN COURT
14:23
PEOPLE’S WITNESS SHYNIKA HUNTER SWORN AND TESTIFIES.
14:49
WITNESS SHYNIKE HUNTER SUBJECT TO RECALL.
PEOPLE’S WITNESS JACOB TOKI SWORN AND TESTIFIES.
15:00
RECESS DECLARED FOR 15 MINUTES
HEARING HELD OUTSIDE PRESENCE OF THE JURY.
15:16
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL JURORS AND ALTERNATE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PLACES.
PEOPLE’S WITNESS JACOB TOKI RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH.
COURTS EXHIBIT(S) 14 ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
COURTS EXHIBIT(S) 8 ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
EXHIBITS 14 8 ARE ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE
THE COURTS EXHIBIT(S) 10 ARE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
EXHIBIT 10 IS ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE
16:08
WITNESS JACOB TOKI SUBJECT TO RECALL.
HEARING HELD OUTSIDE PRESENCE OF THE JURY.
16:21
COURT IS ADJOURNED. JURORS ADMONISHED.
HEARINGS
JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) CONTINUED TO 08/18/2014 AT 10:30 IN DEPARTMENT R14.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – IN CUSTODY
BAIL REMAINS AS SET.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
08/13/2014 10:30 AM DEPT. R14JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) DISPOSED  
Minutes
SHAHLA S SABET, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D4165-TERA SORENSEN
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: LM1-LYNETTE MILAKOVICH CSR# LM1-5098
BAILIFF E. BROCK
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JACK LIU PRESENT.
ATTORNEY RAJAN MALINE PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR JURY TRIAL-IN PROGRESS
2ND DAY OF TRIAL.
10:33
COURT CONVENES OUTSIDE THE PRESENCE OF PROSPECTIVE JURORS.
DISCUSSIONS HELD ON THE RECORD RE: DISCOVERY.
10:37
ALL PROSPECTIVE JURORS ARE NOW PRESENT AND IN
THEIR PROPER PLACES.
PROSPECTIVE JUROR(S) 23 56 51 59 55 AND 13 EXCUSED BY STIPULATION OF COUNSEL.
VOIR DIRE CONTINUES.
PROSPECTIVE JUROR(S) 40 EXCUSED BY STIPULATION OF COUNSEL.
11:37
RECESS DECLARED; JURORS ADMONISHED.
11:42
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL PROSPECTIVE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PROPER PLACES
VOIR DIRE CONTINUES.
11:51
RECESS DECLARED; JURORS ADMONISHED.
1:36
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL PROSPECTIVE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PROPER PLACES
VOIR DIRE CONTINUES.
2:16
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL CONFER IN CHAMBERS
CHAMBERS CONFERENCE ENDS AT 2:20.
PROSPECTIVE JUROR(S) 11 EXCUSED BY STIPULATION OF COUNSEL.
PROSPECTIVE JUROR NUMBER 27 EXCUSED BY PEOPLE’S PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE.
PROSPECTIVE JUROR NUMBER 34 EXCUSED BY DEFENSE PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE.
PROSPECTIVE JUROR NUMBER 30 EXCUSED BY PEOPLE’S PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE.
PROSPECTIVE JUROR NUMBER 64 EXCUSED BY DEFENSE PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE.
PEOPLE ACCEPT THE PANEL AS PRESENTLY CONSTITUTED.
PROSPECTIVE JUROR NUMBER 16 EXCUSED BY DEFENSE PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE.
VOIR DIRE CONTINUES.
PROSPECTIVE JUROR(S) 24 EXCUSED BY STIPULATION OF COUNSEL.
2:42
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
BENCH CONFERENCE ENDS AT 2:43.
PARTIES STIPULATE TO WAIVE RANDOMNESS TO ALLOW
THE FINAL TWO PROSPECTIVE JURORS TO BE CALLED TO
THE JURY BOX.
VOIR DIRE CONTINUES.
2:47
RECESS DECLARED; JURORS ADMONISHED.
3:02
COURT RECONVENES OUTSIDE THE PRESENCE OF PROSPECTIVE JURORS.
CHAMBERS CONFERENCE RECITED INTO THE RECORD.
DISCUSSIONS HELD ON THE RECORD RE: WITNESS.
BAILIFF INDICATES THAT PROSPECTIVE JUROR 02
ADVISED HIM THAT SHE NEEDS TO BE EXCUSED DUE TO
A FAMILY EMERGENCY.
PROSPECTIVE JUROR(S) 02 EXCUSED BY STIPULATION OF COUNSEL.
3:10
ALL PROSPECTIVE JURORS ARE NOW PRESENT AND IN
THEIR PROPER PLACES.
VOIR DIRE CONTINUES.
3:46
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
BENCH CONFERENCE ENDS AT 3:46.
PROSPECTIVE JUROR(S) 06 EXCUSED BY STIPULATION OF COUNSEL.
PROSPECTIVE JUROR NUMBER 08 EXCUSED BY PEOPLE’S PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE.
PROSPECTIVE JUROR NUMBER 01 EXCUSED BY DEFENSE PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE.
PEOPLE ACCEPT THE PANEL AS PRESENTLY CONSTITUTED.
PROSPECTIVE JUROR NUMBER 18 EXCUSED BY DEFENSE PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE.
3:49
12 JURORS AND ZERO ALTERNATES ARE SWORN TO TRY THE CAUSE. THE NAMES OF THE SWORN JURORS AND ALTERNATES ARE SEALED UPON THE RECORDING OF THE VERDICT.
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
BENCH CONFERENCE ENDS AT 3:52.
3:54
ONE ALTERNATE JUROR IS SWORN TO TRY THE CAUSE IF
CALLED UPON AS A TRIAL JUROR.
COURT ADDRESS JURORS.
COURT PRE-INSTRUCTS THE JURY.
4:10
JURORS ARE ADMONISHED AND ADJOURNED.
OUTSIDE THE PRESENCE OF JURORS:
BENCH CONFERENCES RECITED INTO THE RECORD.
4:15
COURT IS ADJOURNED.
HEARINGS
JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) CONTINUED TO 08/14/2014 AT 13:30 IN DEPARTMENT R14.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – IN CUSTODY
BAIL REMAINS AS SET.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
08/12/2014 8:30 AM DEPT. R14ARECALL CALENDAR DISPOSED TRC 
Minutes
SHAHLA S SABET, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D4165-TERA SORENSEN
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: LM1-LYNETTE MILAKOVICH CSR# LM1-5098
BAILIFF E. BROCK
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JACK LIU PRESENT.
ATTORNEY RAJAN MALINE PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME FOR JURY TRIAL
1ST DAY OF TRIAL.
AT 10:06 – COURT CONVENES; ALL PARTIES PRESENT.
DISCUSSIONS HELD ON THE RECORD RE: SCHEDULING
AND TRIAL PROCEDURES.
MOTION(S) IN LIMINE HELD.
PEOPLE STIPULATE TO WAIVE REPORTING OF ANY AUDIO
RECORDINGS THROUGHOUT TRIAL; AND TO USE TRANSCRIPT
IN LIEU OF REPORTING.
10:37
RECESS DECLARED AT THIS TIME.
2:00
JURY PANEL NOW PRESENT, ROLL CALL TAKEN AND ALL PARTIES ARE ACCOUNTED FOR.
PROSPECTIVE JURY PANEL HAVING BEEN SUMMONED, IS SWORN REGARDING THEIR QUALIFICATIONS TO ACT AS TRIAL JURORS.
20:05
COURT IS NOW IN SESSION.
COURT ADDRESS PROSPECTIVE JURORS RE: TRIAL
SCHEDULE.
THE FOLLOWING PROSPECTIVE JURORS HAVE THEIR JURY
DUTY DEFERRED: 28 43 63 31 33 35 15 04 48 66 09
42 49 53 44 41 12 65 37 07 39 58 10 54 AND 20.
PROSPECTIVE JUROR(S) 3 EXCUSED BY STIPULATION OF COUNSEL.
CHARGES ARE READ IN OPEN COURT.
PARTIES ARE INTRODUCED AND POTENTIAL WITNESSES
ARE READ IN OPEN COURT.
PROSPECTIVE JUROR(S) 36 29 50 AND 61 EXCUSED BY STIPULATION OF COUNSEL.
2:42
VOIR DIRE CONDUCTED BY COURT AND COUNSEL.
PROSPECTIVE JUROR(S) 21 EXCUSED BY STIPULATION OF COUNSEL.
PROSPECTIVE JUROR(S) 62 EXCUSED BY STIPULATION OF COUNSEL.
3:07
RECESS DECLARED; JURORS ADMONISHED.
3:21
COURT RECONVENES, ALL PARTIES PRESENT. ALL PROSPECTIVE JURORS ARE PRESENT AND IN THEIR PROPER PLACES
VOIR DIRE CONTINUES.
PROSPECTIVE JUROR(S) 38 EXCUSED BY STIPULATION OF COUNSEL.
3:49
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
BENCH CONFERENCE ENDS AT 3:49.
4:07
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
BENCH CONFERENCE ENDS AT 4:07.
4:13
COURT IS ADJOURNED. JURORS ADMONISHED.
HEARINGS
JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) CONTINUED TO 08/13/2014 AT 10:30 IN DEPARTMENT R14.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – IN CUSTODY
BAIL REMAINS AS SET.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
DEFENDANT ADVISED THAT CASE IS ASSIGNED TO THE SUPERIOR COURT IN DEPARTMENT R14 JUDGE SHAHLA S SABET FOR ALL PURPOSES.

.

Case FWV1300995 Defendant 3767266 RODRIGUEZ , CHRISTIAN ERWIN – Defendants

Seq Defendant Next Court Date Status Agency /
DR Number
Arrest Date Count 1 Charge Violation Date
RODRIGUEZ, CHRISTIAN ERWIN  PRE-TRIAL
11/21/2014 AT 8:30 AM DEPT. R5 
ACTIVE  SH
601300126 
03/19/2013  PC 417(C)  03/19/2013 

Case FWV1300995 Defendant 3767266 RODRIGUEZ , CHRISTIAN ERWIN – Charges

Filed Charges
CountChargeSeverityDescriptionViolation DatePleaStatus
PC 245(C) ADW NOT FIREARM ON PO/FIREFIGHTER:GBI LIKELY 03/19/2013 NOT GUILTY DISCHARGED 
PC 417(C) EXHIBIT FIREARM IN PRESENCE OF PEACE OFFICER 03/19/2013 NOT GUILTY HTA 
PC 245(C) ADW NOT FIREARM ON PO/FIREFIGHTER:GBI LIKELY 03/19/2013 NOT GUILTY DISCHARGED 
PC 69 OBSTR/RESIST EXECUTIVE OFFICER 03/19/2013 NOT GUILTY DISCHARGED 
PC 69 OBSTR/RESIST EXECUTIVE OFFICER 03/19/2013 NOT GUILTY DISCHARGED 
PC 69 OBSTR/RESIST EXECUTIVE OFFICER 03/19/2013 NOT GUILTY HTA 
Infor Charges
CountChargeSeverityDescriptionViolation DatePleaStatus
PC 417(C) EXHIBIT FIREARM IN PRESENCE OF PEACE OFFICER 03/19/2013 NOT GUILTY ACTIVE 
PC 69 OBSTR/RESIST EXECUTIVE OFFICER 03/19/2013 NOT GUILTY ACTIVE 
PC M148(A)(1) OBSTRUCTS/RESISTS/PUBLIC OFCR/ETC 03/19/2013 NOT GUILTY ACTIVE 
PC M148(A)(1) OBSTRUCTS/RESISTS/PUBLIC OFCR/ETC 03/19/2013 NOT GUILTY ACTIVE 
Other Charges
CountChargeSeverityDescriptionViolation DatePleaStatus
999 PC 1203.095 COND OF PROB/MANDATORY JAIL FOR WEAPONS OFFENSE 03/19/2013   

Case FWV1300995 Defendant 3767266 RODRIGUEZ , CHRISTIAN ERWIN – Probation

Probation Has Not Been Granted On This Case For This Defendant.

Case FWV1300995 Defendant 3767266 RODRIGUEZ , CHRISTIAN ERWIN – Actions/Minutes

Action DateAction TextDispositionHearing Type
11/21/2014 8:30 AM DEPT. R5PRE-TRIAL ACTIVE TRC 
10/17/2014 8:30 AM DEPT. R5PRE-TRIAL DISPOSED TRC 
Minutes
COLIN J BILASH, J-JUDGE
CLERK: BMS-BERTHA M. SALAZAR
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: ES-EVA SAGER CSR# ES-4669
BAILIFF A CARBO
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JACK LIU PRESENT.
ATTORNEY CARL DOUGLAS BY AJA MANN PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR PRETRIAL
HEARINGS
HEARING CONTINUED TO 11/21/2014 AT 8:30 IN DEPARTMENT R5.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
TIME WAIVERS
TIME WAIVED TO 01/21/2015.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
09/22/2014TRANSCRIPT BILLING RECEIVED AND FORWARDED TO: FINANCIAL SERVICES    
09/22/2014CT RPTR BILLING RECEIVED AND FORWARDED TO: C VASQUEZ LPSI    
09/22/2014PRELIMINARY HRG TRANSCRIPT TO DA/ATTY CARL E DOUGLAS    
09/22/2014REPORTER’S TRANSCRIPTS OF PRELIMINARY HEARING FILED 09/19/2014.    
09/18/2014 8:31 AM DEPT. R5ARRAIGNMENT ON INFORMATION DISPOSED ARRAIGNMENT 
Minutes
COLIN J BILASH, J-JUDGE
CLERK: BMS-BERTHA M. SALAZAR
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: NSG-NADIA STRAGHALIS GOTT CSR# NSG-12597
BAILIFF A CARBO
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY WILL WOOTEN PRESENT.
SPECIAL APPEARANCE BY ATTORNEY AJA MANN FOR ATTORNEY CARL DOUGLAS.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR ARRAIGNMENT
ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT WAIVES FORMAL ARRAIGNMENT AND ADVISAL OF CONSTITUTIONAL AND STATUTORY RIGHTS.
PLEA INFORMATION
DEFENDANT PLEADS NOT GUILTY TO ALL COUNTS.
MOTIONS
DEFENSE MOTION TO EXONERATE BOND AND RELEASE OR DENIED.
HEARINGS
PRETRIAL SET FOR 10/17/2014 AT 8:30 IN DEPARTMENT %%X %%.
(ALSO SET FOR BAIL HEARING)
CASE CONTINUED FOR DISPO/RESET.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
TIME WAIVERS
DEFENDANT WAIVES TIME TO 10/17/2014 PLUS 90 DAYS.
TIME WAIVED TO 01/17/2015.
FINGERPRINT FORM FILED.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
==MINUTE ORDER CHANGED OR CORRECTED BY B SALAZAR TO DISPO HEARING; CHANGES MADE ARE AS FOLLOWS: DISPO==
=======MINUTE ORDER CORRECTED ON 10/15/2014==========
09/16/2014 8:30 AM DEPT. R5ARRAIGNMENT ON INFORMATION DISPOSED ARRAIGNMENT 
Minutes
COLIN J BILASH, J-JUDGE
CLERK: BMS-BERTHA M. SALAZAR
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: ES-EVA SAGER CSR# ES-4669
BAILIFF A CARBO
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JACK LIU PRESENT.
ATTORNEY CARL DOUGLAS NOT PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR ARRAIGNMENT
DEFENSE COUNSEL ANTABLIN FROM ATTY DOUGLAS
OFFICE CONTACTED COURT REQUESTING CONTINUANCE
TO 09/18/14
HEARINGS
HEARING CONTINUED TO 09/18/2014 AT 8:30 IN DEPARTMENT R5.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
09/10/2014 INFORMATION FILED    
09/10/2014AMENDED INFORMATION FILED   
09/09/2014 10:00 AM DEPT. R9PRELIMINARY HEARING DISPOSED  
Minutes
JON FERGUSON, J-JUDGE
CLERK: VH-VERONICA ORNELAS
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: CG-CYNTHIA GARCIA CSR# CG-12152
BAILIFF L DORTA
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY WILLIAM WOOTON PRESENT.
ATTORNEY CARL DOUGLAS PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING
PEOPLE’S WITNESS STEVEN PENNINGTON (10:33) RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH.
WITNESS STEVEN PENNINGTON (10:58) SUBJECT TO RECALL.
PEOPLE’S WITNESS JAMES POTTS (10:59) SWORN AND TESTIFIES.
PEOPLE’S EXHIBIT(S) 10) 8X10 PHOTO OF PATIO/WOOD MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
PEOPLE’S EXHIBIT(S) 8) 8X10 PHOTO OF WOOD MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
PEOPLE’S EXHIBIT(S) 13) 8X10 PHOTO OF FRONT OF HOUSE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
WITNESS JAMES POTTS (11:13) SUBJECT TO RECALL.
PEOPLE’S WITNESS DANIEL RODRIGUEZ (11:14) SWORN AND TESTIFIES.
PEOPLE’S EXHIBIT(S) 14) 8X10 PHOTO OF SIDE OF PATIO MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
PEOPLE’S EXHIBIT(S) 15) 8X10 PHOTO OF WALK WAY MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
PEOPLE’S EXHIBIT(S) 16) 8X10 PHOTO OF BACKYARD/POOL MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
PEOPLE’S EXHIBIT(S) 11) 8X10 PHOTO OF SWIMMING POOL MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
PEOPLE’S EXHIBIT(S) 12) 8X10 PHOTO OF SPA MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
PEOPLE’S EXHIBIT(S) 17) 8X10 PHOTO OF SWIMMING POOL MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
PEOPLE’S EXHIBIT(S) 18) 8X10 PHOTO OF SWIMMING POOL MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
WITNESS DANIEL RODRIGUEZ (11:43) SUBJECT TO RECALL.
PEOPLE’S EXHIBIT(S) 1-19 ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE.
MOTION BY PEOPLE TO HOLD THE DEFENDANT TO ANSWER IN THE SUPERIOR COURT.
ARGUMENT PRESENTED BY COUNSEL FOR THE DEFENSE.
ARGUMENT PRESENTED BY COUNSEL FOR THE PEOPLE.
COMPLAINT AMENDED AS TO COUNT 2 A VIOLATION OF
PC 417(C).
BY STIPULATION EXHIBITS ORDERED RETURNED TO THE PEOPLE.
COURT MAKES NO ORDER AS TO COUNT(S) 1 3 4 5
ON MOTION OF DA, COURT ORDERS DEFENDANT HELD TO ANSWER IN SUPERIOR COURT TO THE CHARGE(S) IN COUNT(S) 2 6, FELONY(IES).
HEARINGS
ARRAIGNMENT ON INFORMATION SET FOR 09/16/2014 AT 8:30 IN DEPARTMENT R5.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
09/08/2014AFFIDAVIT OF PREJUDICE FILED.   
09/08/2014 9:44 AM DEPT. R14EX PARTE HEARING: RE CCP170.6  DISPOSED  
Minutes
SHAHLA S SABET, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D4165-TERA SORENSEN
BAILIFF E. BROCK
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY WILLIAM WOOTON PRESENT.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR PRE DISPOSITION HEARING
COURT HAS READ AND CONSIDERED PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE
PURSUANT TO CCP170.6 AND FINDS THAT IT IS FILED
TIMELY.
CCP170.6 FILED AS TO JUDGE SHAHLA S SABET CASE REASSIGNED TO DEPARTMENT R9.
HEARINGS
PRELIMINARY HEARING SET ON 09/08/2014 AT 8:30 IN
DEPARTMENT R9.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
ESTIMATED TIME IS 1 DAY.
TIME WAIVERS
TIME WAIVER PREVIOUSLY GIVEN.
TIME WAIVED TO 10/14/2014.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
09/08/2014 8:30 AM DEPT. R9PRELIMINARY HEARING DISPOSED  
Minutes
JON FERGUSON, J-JUDGE
CLERK: VH-VERONICA ORNELAS
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: CG-CYNTHIA GARCIA CSR# CG-12152
BAILIFF L DORTA
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY WILLIAM WOOTON PRESENT.
ATTORNEY CARL DOUGLAS PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING
MOTIONS
MOTION TO EXCLUDE WITNESSES, GRANTED. PEOPLE DESIGNATE DANIEL RODRIGUEZ AS INVESTIGATING OFFICER AND IS EXEMPT FROM THE EXCLUSION.
PEOPLE’S WITNESS MARC SIMPSON (11:07) SWORN AND TESTIFIES.
PEOPLE’S EXHIBIT(S) 1) 8X10 PHOTO OF PARKING LOT MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
WITNESS MARC SIMPSON (11:59) EXCUSED.
DEFENDANT WAIVES RIGHT TO A CONTINUOUS PRELIMINARY HEARING.
RECESS DECLARED AT 11:59
COURT RECONVENES AT 2:06
PEOPLE’S WITNESS CRAIG SIPPLE (2:06) SWORN AND TESTIFIES.
PEOPLE’S EXHIBIT(S) 19) 8X10 MAP MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
PEOPLE’S EXHIBIT(S) 4) 8X10 PHOTO OF WHITE GATE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
PEOPLE’S EXHIBIT(S) 2) 8X10 PHOTO OF YARD MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
PEOPLE’S EXHIBIT(S) 3) 8X10 PHOTO OF PATIO MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
PEOPLE’S EXHIBIT(S) 5) 8X10 PHOTO OF PATIO WITH VICTIM/OFFICERS MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
PEOPLE’S EXHIBIT(S) 9) 8X10 PHOTO OF VICTIM MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
PEOPLE’S EXHIBIT(S) 6) 8X10 PHOTO OF VICTIM MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
PEOPLE’S EXHIBIT(S) 7) 8X10 PHOTO OF TAG 14 MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION.
RECESS DECLARED AT 2:50
COURT RECONVENES AT 2:58
PEOPLE’S WITNESS CRAIG SIPPLE (2:58) RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH.
WITNESS CRAIG SIPPLE (4:02) SUBJECT TO RECALL.
RECESS DECLARED AT 4:02
COURT RECONVENES 4:09
PEOPLE’S WITNESS STEVEN PENNINGTON (4:09) SWORN AND TESTIFIES.
4:28
COURT ADJOURNED
HEARINGS
HEARING CONTINUED TO 09/09/2014 AT 10:00 IN DEPARTMENT R9.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
09/08/2014 8:00 AM DEPT. R18PRELIMINARY HEARING DISPOSED  
Minutes
BRIDGID M. MCCANN, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D4873-TAWNY HAMADA
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: TB-TERESA BORJE CSR# TB-11383
BAILIFF M SMITH
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY WILLIAM WOOTON PRESENT.
ATTORNEY DAVID GOLDSTEIN PRESENT.
ATTORNEY CARLS DOUGLAS PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING
PARTIES ANNOUNCE READY FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING.
ATTORNEY INFORMATION
ATTORNEY DAVID GOLDSTEIN RELIEVED.
ATTORNEY CARL DOUGLAS RETAINED.
HEARINGS
HEARING CONTINUED TO 09/08/2014 AT 8:30 IN DEPARTMENT R14.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
ESTIMATED TIME: 1 DAY
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
08/12/2014 8:00 AM DEPT. R18PRELIMINARY HEARING DISPOSED  
Minutes
BRIDGID M. MCCANN, J-JUDGE
CLERK: B6457-TAMMY BREINER
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: TB-TERESA BORJE CSR# TB-11383
BAILIFF M SMITH
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JEREMY CARRASCO PRESENT.
ATTORNEY DAVID GOLDSTEIN PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING
PEOPLE NOT READY TO PROCEED WITH PRELIMINARY
HEARING.
(OVER DEFENSE OBJECTION)
COURT ADVISES COUNSEL THIS IS LAST CONTINUANCE.
HEARINGS
PRELIMINARY HEARING SET ON 09/08/2014 AT 8:30 IN DEPARTMENT R18.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
ESTIMATED TIME IS 1 DAY.
TIME WAIVERS
TIME WAIVER PREVIOUSLY GIVEN.
TIME WAIVED TO 10/14/2014.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
06/25/2014 8:00 AM DEPT. R18PRELIMINARY HEARING DISPOSED  
Minutes
JERRY E JOHNSON, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D4873-TAWNY HAMADA
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: TB-TERESA BORJE CSR# TB-11383
BAILIFF M SMITH
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JEREMY CARRASCO PRESENT.
ATTORNEY DAVID GOLDSTEIN PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING
MATTER CONTINUED BY STIPULATION.
HEARINGS
PRELIMINARY HEARING SET ON 08/12/2014 AT 8:00 IN DEPARTMENT R18.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
ESTIMATED TIME: 1 DAY
TIME WAIVERS
DEFENDANT WAIVES HIS/HER RIGHT TO A PRELIMINARY HEARING WITHIN 10 COURT DAYS AND 60 CALENDAR DAYS UNDER PC859B AND 60 DAYS BEYOND 08/12/2014.
TIME WAIVED TO 10/14/2014.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
06/02/2014 8:30 AM DEPT. R18PRE-PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE DISPOSED TRC 
Minutes
BRIDGID M. MCCANN, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D3106-DAISY CENTENO
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: TB-TERESA BORJE CSR# TB-11383
BAILIFF M SMITH
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JEREMY CARRASCO PRESENT.
ATTORNEY DAVID GOLDSTEIN PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR PRE-PRELIMINARY HEARING
PARTIES ANNOUNCE READY FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING.
HEARINGS
PRELIMINARY HEARING SET ON 06/25/2014 AT 8:00 IN DEPARTMENT R18.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
ESTIMATED TIME IS 4-6 HOURS.
TIME WAIVERS
TIME WAIVER PREVIOUSLY GIVEN.
TIME WAIVED TO 08/01/2014.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
05/12/2014AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED.   
05/12/2014 8:00 AM DEPT. R18PRELIMINARY HEARING DISPOSED  
Minutes
BRIDGID M. MCCANN, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D4873-TAWNY HAMADA
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: TB-TERESA BORJE CSR# TB-11383
BAILIFF M SMITH
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY WILLIAM WOOTEN PRESENT.
ATTORNEY DAVID GOLDSTEIN PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING
AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED.
DEFENSE COUNSEL WAIVES FORMAL ARRAIGNMENT ON AMENDED COMPLAINT.
PLEA INFORMATION
DEFENDANT PLEADS NOT GUILTY TO ALL COUNTS.
HEARINGS
PRE-PRELIMINARY HEARING SET FOR 06/02/2014 AT 8:30 IN DEPARTMENT R18.
CASE CONTINUED FOR DISPO/RESET.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
TIME WAIVERS
DEFENDANT WAIVES HIS/HER RIGHT TO A PRELIMINARY HEARING WITHIN 10 COURT DAYS AND 60 CALENDAR DAYS UNDER PC859B AND 60 DAYS BEYOND 06/02/2014.
TIME WAIVED TO 08/01/2014.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
05/05/2014DBID DEBIT CARD TRANSACTION ID 023-0206024488.    
05/05/2014 MISCELLANEOUS PAYMENT OF $30.50 RECEIVED.    
04/29/2014 8:00 AM DEPT. R18PRELIMINARY HEARING DISPOSED  
Minutes
STEPHAN G SALESON, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D4873-TAWNY HAMADA
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: TB-TERESA BORJE CSR# TB-11383
BAILIFF M SMITH
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY WILL WOOTON BY JEREMY CARRASCO PRESENT.
ATTORNEY DAVID GOLDSTEIN PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING
AT THE REQUEST OF COUNSEL
HEARINGS
PRELIMINARY HEARING SET ON 05/12/2014 AT 8:00 IN DEPARTMENT R18.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
ESTIMATED TIME IS 1 DAY.
TIME WAIVERS
TIME WAIVED FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING; PLUS 60 DAYS.
TIME WAIVED TO 07/14/2014.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
04/10/2014 8:00 AM DEPT. R18PRELIMINARY HEARING VACATED  
04/08/2014 8:30 AM DEPT. R18PRE-PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE DISPOSED TRC 
Minutes
BRIDGID M. MCCANN, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D4873-TAWNY HAMADA
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: TB-TERESA BORJE CSR# TB-11383
BAILIFF M SMITH
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY WILL WOOTON PRESENT.
ATTORNEY DAVID GOLDSTEIN PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR PRE-PRELIMINARY HEARING
OFF THE RECORD, COURT AND COUNSEL AT BENCH.
DEFENSE MOTION TO REDUCE BAIL IS GRANTED.
BAIL SET AT $100000.00.
HEARINGS
PRELIMINARY HEARING SET ON 04/29/2014 AT 8:00 IN DEPARTMENT R18.
PRELIMINARY HEARING SET ON 04/10/2014 VACATED.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
ESTIMATED TIME: 1 DAY
TIME WAIVERS
TIME WAIVED TO 05/27/2014.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
02/20/2014 8:00 AM DEPT. R18PRELIMINARY HEARING VACATED  
02/13/2014 8:30 AM DEPT. R18PRE-PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE DISPOSED TRC 
Minutes
BRIDGID M. MCCANN, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D4873-TAWNY HAMADA
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: ASV-ALICIA S. VASQUEZ CSR# ASV-12225
BAILIFF M SMITH
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY WILL WOOTON PRESENT.
ATTORNEY DAVID GOLDSTEIN PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR PRE-PRELIMINARY HEARING
HEARINGS
PRE-PRELIMINARY HEARING SET FOR 04/08/2014 AT 8:30 IN DEPARTMENT R18.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
PRELIMINARY HEARING SET ON 04/10/2014 AT 8:00 IN DEPARTMENT R18.
TIME WAIVERS
DEFENDANT WAIVES HIS/HER RIGHT TO A PRELIMINARY HEARING WITHIN 10 COURT DAYS AND 60 CALENDAR DAYS UNDER PC859B AND 45 DAYS BEYOND 04/10/2014.
TIME WAIVED TO 05/27/2014.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
PRELIMINARY HEARING SET ON 02/20/2014 VACATED.
01/14/2014 8:30 AM DEPT. R18PRE-PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE DISPOSED TRC 
Minutes
BRIDGID M. MCCANN, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D6022-AMBER ANDERSON
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: TB-TERESA BORJE CSR# TB-11383
BAILIFF T CARBO
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JEREMY CARRASCO PRESENT.
CONFLICT DEFENSE PANEL DAVID GOLDSTEIN PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR PRE-PRELIMINARY HEARING
HEARINGS
PRE-PRELIMINARY HEARING SET FOR 02/13/2014 AT 8:30 IN DEPARTMENT R18.
PRELIMINARY HEARING SET ON 02/20/2014 AT 8:00 IN DEPARTMENT R18.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
TIME WAIVERS
DEFENDANT WAIVES HIS/HER RIGHT TO A PRELIMINARY HEARING WITHIN 10 COURT DAYS AND 60 CALENDAR DAYS UNDER PC859B AND 60 DAYS BEYOND 02/20/2014.
TIME WAIVED TO 04/21/2014.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
11/14/2013 8:00 AM DEPT. R18PRELIMINARY HEARING VACATED  
11/12/2013 8:30 AM DEPT. R18PRE-PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE DISPOSED TRC 
Minutes
RONALD J GILBERT, C-COMMISSIONER
CLERK: D4873-TAWNY HAMADA
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: TB-TERESA BORJE CSR# TB-11383
BAILIFF E. CHAMPIN
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JEREMY CARRASCO PRESENT.
CONFLICT DEFENSE PANEL DAVID GOLDSTEIN PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR PRE-PRELIMINARY HEARING
HEARINGS
PRE-PRELIMINARY HEARING SET FOR 01/14/2014 AT 8:30 IN DEPARTMENT R18.
CASE CONTINUED FOR DISPO/RESET.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
TIME WAIVERS
DEFENDANT WAIVES HIS/HER RIGHT TO A PRELIMINARY HEARING WITHIN 10 COURT DAYS AND 60 CALENDAR DAYS UNDER PC859B AND 45 DAYS BEYOND 01/14/2014.
TIME WAIVED TO 02/28/2014.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
PRELIMINARY HEARING SET ON 11/14/2013 VACATED.
10/08/2013 8:30 AM DEPT. R18PRE-PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE DISPOSED TRC 
Minutes
CARA D HUTSON, J-JUDGE
CLERK: MV-MARY VIZCARRA
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: TB-TERESA BORJE CSR# TB-11383
BAILIFF A. CARBO
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JEREMY CARRASCO PRESENT.
ATTORNEY DAVID M. GOLDSTEIN PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR PRE-PRELIMINARY HEARING
HEARINGS
PRE-PRELIMINARY HEARING SET FOR 11/12/2013 AT 8:30 IN DEPARTMENT R18.
PRELIMINARY HEARING SET ON 11/14/2013 AT 8:00 IN DEPARTMENT R18.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
TIME WAIVERS
DEFENDANT WAIVES HIS/HER RIGHT TO A PRELIMINARY HEARING WITHIN 10 COURT DAYS AND 60 CALENDAR DAYS UNDER PC859B AND 60 DAYS BEYOND 11/14/2013.
TIME WAIVED TO 01/13/2014.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
09/17/2013 8:30 AM DEPT. R18PRE-PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE DISPOSED TRC 
Minutes
CARA D HUTSON, J-JUDGE
CLERK: E5326-MONICA LOPEZ
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: TB-TERESA BORJE CSR# TB-11383
BAILIFF A. CARBO
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY JEREMY CARRASCO PRESENT.
ATTORNEY DAVID M. GOLDSTEIN PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR PRE-PRELIMINARY HEARING
MATTER CONTINUED FOR THE PURPOSES OF DISCOVERY.
HEARINGS
PRE-PRELIMINARY HEARING SET FOR 10/08/2013 AT 8:30 IN DEPARTMENT R18.
CASE CONTINUED FOR DISPO/RESET.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
TIME WAIVERS
TIME WAIVED TO 11/18/2013.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
08/08/2013 8:30 AM DEPT. R18PRE-PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE DISPOSED TRC 
Minutes
CARA D HUTSON, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D4873-TAWNY HAMADA
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: TB-TERESA BORJE CSR# TB-11383
BAILIFF S. YOUNG
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY WILLIAM WOOTEN PRESENT.
ATTORNEY DAVID M. GOLDSTEIN PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR PRE-PRELIMINARY HEARING
HEARINGS
HEARING CONTINUED TO 09/17/2013 AT 8:30 IN DEPARTMENT R18.
CASE CONTINUED FOR DISPO/RESET.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
TIME WAIVERS
DEFENDANT WAIVES HIS/HER RIGHT TO A PRELIMINARY HEARING WITHIN 10 COURT DAYS AND 60 CALENDAR DAYS UNDER PC859B AND 60 DAYS BEYOND 09/17/2013.
TIME WAIVED TO 11/18/2013.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
07/18/2013 8:30 AM DEPT. R18PRE-PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE DISPOSED TRC 
Minutes
CARA D HUTSON, J-JUDGE
CLERK: MV-MARY VIZCARRA
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: TB-TERESA BORJE CSR# TB-11383
BAILIFF S. YOUNG
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY WILLIAM WOOTEN PRESENT.
ATTORNEY DAVID M. GOLDSTEIN PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR PRE-PRELIMINARY HEARING
HEARINGS
PRE-PRELIMINARY HEARING SET FOR 08/08/2013 AT 8:30 IN DEPARTMENT R18.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
CASE CONTINUED FOR DISPO/RESET.
TIME WAIVERS
DEFENDANT WAIVES HIS/HER RIGHT TO A PRELIMINARY HEARING WITHIN 10 COURT DAYS AND 60 CALENDAR DAYS UNDER PC859B AND 60 DAYS BEYOND 08/08/2013.
TIME WAIVED TO 10/07/2013.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
06/20/2013 8:30 AM DEPT. R18PRE-PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE DISPOSED TRC 
Minutes
CARA D HUTSON, J-JUDGE
CLERK: MV-MARY VIZCARRA
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: VV-VICTORIA VILLEGAS CSR# VV-9843
BAILIFF S YOUNG
APPEARANCES
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY WILLIAM WOOTEN PRESENT.
ATTORNEY DAVID M. GOLDSTEIN PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR PRE-PRELIMINARY HEARING
HEARINGS
PRE-PRELIMINARY HEARING SET FOR 07/18/2013 AT 8:30 IN DEPARTMENT R18.
CASE CONTINUED FOR DISPO/RESET.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
TIME WAIVERS
DEFENDANT WAIVES HIS/HER RIGHT TO A PRELIMINARY HEARING WITHIN 10 COURT DAYS AND 60 CALENDAR DAYS UNDER PC859B AND 60 DAYS BEYOND 07/18/2013.
TIME WAIVED TO 09/16/2013.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
06/04/2013 8:00 AM DEPT. R18PRELIMINARY HEARING VACATED  
05/29/2013 8:30 AM DEPT. R18PRE-PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE DISPOSED TRC 
Minutes
CARA D HUTSON, J-JUDGE
CLERK: V0837-MARY VIZCARRA
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: VV-VICTORIA VILLEGAS CSR# VV-9843
BAILIFF S. YOUNG
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY WILLIAM WOOTEN PRESENT.
ATTORNEY DAVID M. GOLDSTEIN PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR PRE-PRELIMINARY HEARING
HEARINGS
HEARING CONTINUED TO 06/20/2013 AT 8:30 IN DEPARTMENT R18.
CASE CONTINUED FOR DISPO/RESET.
PRELIMINARY HEARING SET ON 06/04/2013 VACATED.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
TIME WAIVERS
DEFENDANT WAIVES HIS/HER RIGHT TO A PRELIMINARY HEARING WITHIN 10 COURT DAYS AND 60 CALENDAR DAYS UNDER PC859B AND 60 DAYS BEYOND 06/20/2013.
TIME WAIVED TO 08/19/2013.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
CURRENT BAIL BOND CONTINUED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
05/23/2013 8:30 AM DEPT. R18ARRAIGNMENT DISPOSED ARRAIGNMENT 
Minutes
CARA D HUTSON, J-JUDGE
CLERK: D4873-TAWNY HAMADA
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER: TC-TRICIA CHAMBERLAIN CSR# TC-12911
BAILIFF S. YOUNG
APPEARANCES
ATTORNEY DAVID M. GOLDSTEIN PRESENT.
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
ATTORNEY INFORMATION
ATTORNEY DAVID M. GOLDSTEIN RETAINED.
COPY OF COMPLAINT AND DISCOVERY GIVEN TO DEFENSE COUNSEL.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR ARRAIGNMENT
ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT WAIVES FORMAL ARRAIGNMENT AND ADVISAL OF CONSTITUTIONAL AND STATUTORY RIGHTS.
PLEA INFORMATION
DEFENDANT PLEADS NOT GUILTY TO ALL COUNTS.
HEARINGS
PRE-PRELIMINARY HEARING SET FOR 05/29/2013 AT 8:30 IN DEPARTMENT R18.
PRELIMINARY HEARING SET ON 06/04/2013 AT 8:00 IN DEPARTMENT R18.
DEFENDANT ORDERED TO APPEAR ON HEARING DATE.
TIME WAIVERS
10TH DAY IS 06/07/2013.
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
DISTRICT ATTORNEY NOTIFIED.
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
05/23/2013 8:00 AM DEPT. R19ARRAIGNMENT DISPOSED ARRAIGNMENT 
Minutes
MICHAEL R LIBUTTI, J-JUDGE
CLERK: B6457-TAMMY BREINER
BAILIFF K OLIVA
APPEARANCES
DEFENDANT PRESENT NOT IN CUSTODY.
PROCEEDINGS
ACTION CAME ON FOR ARRAIGNMENT
JUDGE LIBUTTI RECUSES HIMSELF/HERSELF. CASE RE-ASSIGNED TO DEPARTMENT R18 JUDGE CARA D HUTSON FOR ALL PURPOSES.
(PURSUANT TO CCP170.1(6)(A)(I))
HEARINGS
CUSTODY STATUS
CASE CUSTODY – BAIL BOND
============= MINUTE ORDER END ================
03/28/2013 BOND POSTED FOR 110000.00    
03/21/2013CASE REASSIGNED TO RS- RANCHO DISTRICT.    
03/21/2013 EFILE DA INTERFACE ENTRY    

Case FWV1300995 Defendant 3767266 RODRIGUEZ , CHRISTIAN ERWIN – Fine Information

  Date To Pay: N/A First Payment:
Prior NSF: Payment Amount: $0.00 Last Payment:

 

Fine Number Fine Type Fine Description Original Amount Paid To Date Current Due
           
Total: $0.00  $0.00  $0.00 

Case FWV1300995 Defendant 3767266 RODRIGUEZ , CHRISTIAN ERWIN – Payment Information

Date Action Description Receipt Number Amount
05/05/2014  Miscellaneous Payment of $30.50 Received.  20140505-1035 $30.50